Disc 1. Silent night (3:39) -- All I want for Christmas is you (4:01) -- O holy night (4:27) -- Christmas (Baby please come home) (2:33) -- Miss you most (at Christmas time) (4:32) -- Joy to the world (4:18) -- Jesus born on this day (3:41) -- Santa Claus is comin' to town (3:24) -- Hark! the herald angels sing/Gloria (in excelsis Deo) (2:59) -- Jesus oh what a wonderful child (4:26) -- God rest ye merry gentlemen (1:19).

Disc 2. Sugar plum fairy introlude (0:44) -- All I want for Christmas is you (live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine) (5:06) -- Silent night (live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine) (3:44) -- Joy to the world (live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine) (5:40) -- Hark! the herald angels sing/Gloria (in excelsis Deo) (live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine) (3:03) -- Jesus born on this day (live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine) (3:46) -- Santa Claus is comin' to town (live at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine) (3:27) -- Oh Santa! (3:31) -- Christmas time is in the air again (3:02) -- When Christmas comes / (duet with John Legend) (4:45) -- The star (4:01) -- Lil snowman (3:19) -- Santa Claus is comin' to town (anniversary mix) (2:46) -- All I want for Christmas is you (So So Def remix) / (featuring Jermaine Dupri & Lil' Bow Wow) (3:43) -- All I want for Christmas is you (Mariah's new dance mix extended 2009) (6:42) -- Joy to the world (celebration mix) (8:00) -- Joy to the world (flava mix) (7:03) -- Sugar plum fairy introlude (acapella) (0:40).